In a market saturated with formulaic crime novels, Jerry Pinto’s Murder in the Mahim stands apart as a crime story that blends suspense with soul. First published a few years ago and now trending again thanks to its recent re-release and growing popularity on Indian Bookstagram, this gritty novel has returned to bestseller lists in June 2025, bolstered by new readers and word-of-mouth buzz.
This is more than a whodunit—it’s a piercing look at urban life, caste, sexuality, and father-son relationships in contemporary India, all wrapped in the unpredictable lanes of Mahim, Mumbai.
🔪 Buy *Murder in the Mahim* on Amazon India🔍 Plot Summary: A Crime in the Shadows
The novel opens with the discovery of a young man’s brutalized body in a public toilet near Mahim station. Peter Fernandes, a retired journalist with personal ties to the victim’s family, is pulled into the case alongside Inspector Zende, a longtime acquaintance with his own moral compass.
What follows is a riveting investigation that takes readers deep into Mumbai’s queer underground, slums, and press rooms—shedding light on secrets that powerful people want to keep buried.
At the core is Peter’s relationship with his own son, Sunil, who is gay and distant, forcing Peter to confront not only the city’s hidden crimes but his own biases and emotional failures.
✍️ Jerry Pinto’s Craft: Crime With Compassion
Pinto, known for his powerful memoir Em and the Big Hoom, brings his characteristic empathy and poetic language to the crime genre. While the novel follows a classic detective structure, it refuses to flatten its characters into stereotypes.
His Mumbai is a living, breathing character—hot, crowded, contradictory. From the scent of cutting chai at street stalls to the chaos of train compartments, Pinto draws Mumbai in strokes that are both precise and heartfelt.
Most importantly, Murder in the Mahim refuses to shy away from topics considered taboo: homosexuality, classism, communal tensions, and familial dysfunction. It is as much a social critique as a crime mystery.
🚇 Enter the Underbelly of Mumbai🎯 Key Themes
- Queer Identity in Urban India: The book offers one of the most empathetic portrayals of queer characters in Indian crime fiction.
- Father-Son Conflict: Peter’s internal journey is as significant as the external investigation.
- Social Hypocrisy: Pinto lays bare how class and sexual orientation impact justice and perception.
- Media Ethics & Political Games: As an ex-journalist, Peter’s insights highlight the shifting ethics in India’s newsrooms.
- Urban Grit & Grace: A love letter and a critique of Mumbai in equal measure.
📈 Reception & Popularity
Since being picked up again in June 2025 by reading clubs and queer literature circles, Murder in the Mahim has seen:
- A new Collector’s Edition re-released with author notes
- Featured in Amazon India’s Top 10 Indian Fiction List
- Buzz across Instagram and YouTube via #CrimeReadsIndia and #JerryPinto
- Endorsements from authors like Anita Nair and Manu Joseph
It’s currently trending among metro readers aged 25–45, especially in Delhi, Mumbai, and Bengaluru.
💬 What Readers Are Saying
“I picked it up as a murder mystery. I stayed for the emotions.”
– Rahul Mehra, Goodreads Review
“Jerry Pinto should be on every Indian reader’s shelf. Crime fiction with a conscience.”
– @theurbanbooknerd, Instagram Bookstagrammer
“A rare book that talks about masculinity, fear, and compassion without melodrama.”
– Devika Sinha, Twitter
💡 Why You Should Read This Book
Murder in the Mahim is perfect for readers who:
- Want a gripping mystery that also has depth
- Enjoy Indian fiction rooted in real urban experiences
- Seek representation of LGBTQ+ themes with nuance
- Appreciate literary prose in genre fiction
- Are looking for a thought-provoking, emotionally rewarding read
If you’ve loved books by Vikram Chandra or Neel Mukherjee, this belongs on your reading list.
Read more such articles only on- Authors and Books
