Before We Were Strangers by Renée Carlino – A Heart-Stirring Tale of Love, Loss & What Could Have Been

What if the love of your life was someone you let walk away?

Renée Carlino’s Before We Were Strangers is not just another second-chance romance. It’s a bittersweet, soul-searching reflection on the passage of time, the fragility of love, and the moments that slip between our fingers when we think we have forever. With poetic prose and a New York City setting drenched in nostalgia, Carlino crafts a story that is as much about rediscovering love as it is about rediscovering yourself.

Plot Summary: A Craigslist Missed Connection Sparks the Past

The story begins with a Craigslist ad.

Matt and Grace were once inseparable—art school students in NYC who shared music, dreams, and the kind of youthful connection that comes once in a lifetime. But somewhere along the line, as careers took off and life intervened, they drifted apart. Now, years later, Matt—divorced, a photographer for National Geographic, and emotionally worn—spots Grace on a subway platform. Before he can reach her, she vanishes.

So he does the unthinkable: he posts a missed connection online, hoping fate might help him find her again.

What follows is a dual-timeline narrative. One thread traces their electric college days, full of late-night jam sessions and raw vulnerability; the other takes us through their unexpected reunion and the tangled emotions that come with it.

Themes: Time, Timing, and the Roads Not Taken

What sets Before We Were Strangers apart is its honest, heartfelt examination of how life doesn’t always unfold the way we plan, and how the right person at the wrong time can become a memory that haunts every other relationship.

Carlino captures that aching space between what was and what might still be. It’s not just a love story—it’s about growing up, drifting apart, and wondering if we ever truly stop loving our first real connection.

Grace and Matt’s story is filled with longing, missed chances, and moments that feel like they’re lifted straight from real life. It’s a book that will make you pause and reflect on your own “what ifs.”

Writing Style: Melancholic Yet Hopeful

Carlino’s writing is intimate and lyrical, with a subtle emotional power. She excels at capturing internal monologue and emotional nuance without becoming melodramatic. The transitions between past and present are smooth, each memory giving depth to the characters’ reunion in the present.

The New York setting is not just a backdrop—it’s a character in itself. From dive bars and student apartments to quiet subway moments, Carlino paints the city in warm tones of nostalgia and possibility. Readers who’ve ever lived in or dreamed of New York will find themselves emotionally anchored in its rhythm.

Characters That Feel Like People You Know

Matt is flawed but deeply likable—idealistic as a young man, and jaded yet yearning as an adult. Grace is grounded, artistic, and strong, but she too carries the burden of lost time and unmet expectations.

Their chemistry is palpable, but it’s the emotional connection—the late-night conversations, the shared ambitions, the gentle acts of care—that makes their relationship so believable and engrossing.

Supporting characters like Matt’s mom, Grace’s friends, and even a few unnamed city dwellers add texture and realism to the narrative, reminding us that sometimes strangers shape our stories just as deeply as lovers do.

Why This Book Resonates

Before We Were Strangers is a deeply personal read for anyone who’s ever wondered what happened to a lost love—or what might happen if they returned. It doesn’t rely on tropes to manufacture drama; it trusts in the emotional truth of distance, time, and reconnection.

There’s a quiet magic in how Carlino handles forgiveness and hope. She doesn’t promise fairy-tale endings, but she offers something better: the idea that it’s never too late to reach for what truly matters.

Read more such articles only on – Authors and Books